Thanks for the nice comments. I’m not even really calling out anybody in particular—I think we should note that the Shakespeare’s Sister site also has kept track of many of the racist/secret Muslim smears launched against the Obamas. But I definitely feel that the Clinton campaign’s overt attempts to use race as a wedge issue were given more of a pass by some feminist commentators, who then tried really hard to find sexist intent in everything Obama did. Do I think he’s entirely free of male privilege? Um, no. But I think he was far more respectful of his female opponent than she was of him—he never, to my knowledge, implied that John McCain was more worthy of the Oval Office than Hillary Clinton, for one thing.
But then I read ridiculous things pn several sites claiming things like “Well, it’s obviously easier to get elected in this country if you’re black than if you’re a woman,”
A) That’s obviously not true, because there are more white women in the United States Senate right now than there have ever been black senators of either gender—same with state governors.
B) Even if that’s true, why is it inherently problematic that barriers of race come down before gender? Can anyone honestly argue that black people of both genders have historically had a harder row to hoe than a lot of white women?
I had to dump one online friendship with a woman in Australia who was very invested in Hillary and kept beating the drum that Obama was an empty suit, he hadn’t done anything, he was deliberately running when he knew it was—wait for it—HILLARY’S TURN and how dare he? And she argued that it was so much easier to be black in America than a woman. (As if she would fucking know about race in America to start with. As a white woman, I can’t claim to understand all the racial nuances in this country, and I live here.)
Finally, I asked her if she would honestly want to trade places with an aborigine male in her country, given that she believed his gender gave him advantages over her (white, highly educated) female self. No answer. Which is in itself an answer.
I don’t like arguing the rights of black people vs. women or lesbians vs. feminist battles as a rule, because I think they play into the “let’s you and her fight” strategy of the dominant power structures. But when people like Gloria Steinem, Erica Jong (ugh) and Robin Morgan began their intellectually dishonest and insulting arguments for Hillary that managed to promote the “this black guy is an empty suit and women who support him are gender traitors and dumb little manpleasing whores” meme (mostly Morgan and Jong there), then I part ways with the feminist power structure.
Comment by Kerry Reid on
09/24/08 at 06:28 PM