Just remember, we’re talking about a guy who believes Hitler was a Socialist Democrat, because the Nazi party had the word “Socialist” in its name and there’s a “D” in NSDAP. Jonah probably thinks the Freemasons are a trade-school for bricklayers and Birchers plant trees on Arbor Day.
Jonah is so convinced of the negative attack value of the label “Socialist” that he will brook no dilution of the word nor any admission of the truth that it is not in fact an absolute concept with a fixed definition that it is ALWAYS EVIL. That he can only defend that position with word games and crappy analogies should come as no surprise to regular readers and people who bought his book. This was a particularly lazy and ineffective post, however, albeit on a blog where Lazy and Ineffective are registered trademarks.
That Socialism (government seizure and distribution of land) settled the continent and was happily applied by both Nixon (wage and price controls) and Reagan (Federal takeover of air traffic control) as a useful and necessary tool of government are imperfect arguments against Goldberg’s book-length term paper, but by raising them I have already given more thought to Jonah than he gave to Cohen.