I believe everything I read (and hear) on the Internet

I was bopping around YouTube checking out town hall videos and stumbled upon this nonsense:

It has nearly 9000 views and 177 comments.  In it George, who is working on two “totally awesome” movies about debt and inflation, lets the viewer know that he’s concerned about the “lies and deceit” the Obama “propaganda machine,” in conjunction with the complicit media, were manufacturing about the president’s recent town hall in Belgrade, Montana. George has a “source” who works at “the airport” in Montana and he told him a bunch of shocking things.  Right off the bat George, who is a very truthful man, says Belgrade is “probably the most remote location you could chose to have a presidential meeting. You could not pick a more remote location according to my source.” In addition, “there were reports on the radio station that thousands of dollars were paid to ship in lobster to eat. Why on earth would you be eating lobster when Montana is known as one of the best places in the country to eat beef?” George, who is a very truthful man, also makes several other allegations.  Watch it if you have a few minutes.

A quick look at Google maps shows you that Belgrade isn’t all that remote at all (especially for Montana). It’s conveniently located off of interstate highway 90 and even have its own airport (I assume this is the one George’s “source” works at).  Wikipedia also lists Belgrade as one of Montana’s “major towns.”  In addition, a quick Google search shows that George was lying about having a “source” (surprise!) and picked up all of the “facts” that he trots out in his video from an unverified comment that was spammed all over the rightosphere in mid-August and also distributed via email.  Here’s one example of it in the blogosphere and FactCheck.org picked up the email.

Not much to add to this.  It’s just startling how quickly untruths circulate thanks to the Internet and real propaganda outlets like FOX News. I’m at a loss as to how to beat this insanity. Fact checking is great, but it only works if people are intellectually curious and/or honest enough to listen.  Unfortunately, I think most of these teabaggers are neither and never will be. So the only solution I see is to keep exposing their inanity (and outright mocking them) and hope the wobbly folks in the middle will be appalled enough to want to keep their distance from them and, ya know, not believe everything they read on the Internet.

Posted by Kevin K. on 09/02/09 at 10:53 AM • Permalink

Categories: PoliticsBarack ObamaHealth CareNuttersSkull HampersYouTubidity

Share this post:  Share via Twitter   Share via BlinkList   Share via del.icio.us   Share via Digg   Share via Email   Share via Facebook   Share via Fark   Share via NewsVine   Share via Propeller   Share via Reddit   Share via StumbleUpon   Share via Technorati  

His editing is so effortless. Literally.

What. An. Ass.

The original email became blog-visible on Aug 22, and was reported on FreeRepublic complete with the “This is a very real a real letter a very good friend of mine got from a friend of hers who attended the Town Hall in Montana” set-up.

It was obviously bullshit Weboganda, but it rapidly went viral. More than the usual number of wingnuts smelled “spam,” but most were hooked by the time they got to the surefire paydirt line:

This same morning someone called into the radio from the local UPS branch and said that THOUSANDS of Dollars of Lobster were shipped in for Obama.

As an example of the genre, it’s really a classic, right down to the gossipy “on the QT” tone of the text and the judicious use of seemingly authentic ground-level details that couldn’t possibly be disputed by anyone who doesn’t live in Boseman or Belgrade.

I admire the cynical craftsmanship of the letter, and the sheer number of unspoken hates and fears it was able to key into. However, once the writer struck the mother-lode of Black-Emperor-Who-Spends-Thousands-of-Dollars-on-Lobster-to- Feed-His-Gangsta-Posse-in-the-Middle-of-a-Recession indignation, everything else was gravy.

I have plenty of t-shirts, a lot of ‘em, seriously, but they are all amateurs, not a professional t-shirt among the whole lot. I guess my t-shirts are just NCAA Division III t-shirts, not like, NFL professional t-shirts.

What in the name of Harry Hill is it with the wingnuts and this lobster snack fixation?

Remember this one from last year, kited and blown out of the water
within days, but still gracing the archives of a number of blogs that shall not be named because they have no shame?

Lobster: expensive, elitist, rich people’s food. No, Obama wouldn’t be ordering filet mignon, because that’s red meat, like real men eat. Lobster is the new arugula.

“ummmm hi everyone;
My name is George and I have a really, like you know, awesome camcorder and I’m making a movie, no wait 2 really awesome movies…”

WOW!?!

And the Academy Award for Best Film is…

Funny how a hundred years ago lobster, hell almost all shellfish was considered poor people’s food. They were plentiful both in the sea and once trapped, on land.

But do Muslims eat shellfish?

Funny how a hundred years ago lobster, hell almost all shellfish was considered poor people’s food.

Yup. Servants and laborers over here used to have contracts specifying that they could be fed oysters and salmon only so many times a week!

What in the name of Harry Hill is it with the wingnuts and this lobster snack fixation?

I immediately thought of that too.  Wingers don’t have much imagination.  All those elitists just eat LOBSTER every day.

Well, I’m going to apply the same standard of fact-checking as George did, and rely on some stuff I got told by somebody somewhere - in this case, in the comments on his video.

siloria (1 week ago)

1. Remote Location - FALSE Belgrade is 6 miles from one of the largest cities (Bozeman) in the state of Montana. Is it small? Yes, but we are a small state population wise.

2. Cargo Shipped In - TRUE This townhall was held in a hanger at the Airport to avoid disruption to the local economy and police force. This could not have been done more cheaply if Obama wanted to have a town hall in Montana.

3. Only 600 tickets passed out = FALSE This is simply not true. A total of 884 tickets were distributed between Bozeman and Belgrade. The hanger in question had a capacity of 1500 less room for the stage, media, and security. There were a total of 1300 tickets.

4. Lobster was shipped in - FALSE No reputable source has backed up this claim but why worry about truth when you can just as easily make stuff up?

5. SEIU Member counter-protest - TRUE It was not only SEIU members but they did make up a chunk of those supporting healthcare reform. It should be noted that  SEIU is the largest union of Nurses and other healthcare workers so their opinion is actually relevant to this debate.

Please feel free to check the statements I have made here and think about checking statements made by partisans who will oppose everything Obama does.

Given the lack of evidence, siloria’s at least as credible as George (in fact, I’m being over-generous to George, since what can be checked out favors siloria’s account).

Amazing that even the wingnuts would believe Obama shipped lobster to Montana when everyone knows he and Biden love hamburgers.

But then, wingnuts love nothing more better than hogwash.

probably the most remote location you could chose to have a presidential meeting. You could not pick a more remote location according to my source.

Oh, bollocks.  I’ve been to Monhegan Island, Maine, which has no paved roads and is accessible only by boat (the ferry takes about an hour.)  And that’s probably not even in America’s Remoteness Top 40.

Comment by Steve M. on 09/03/09 at 02:31 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages

Sorry, commenting is closed for this post.

<< Back to main