Judge Carter to Orly: It’s Been Interesting, Buh-Bye.

Carter dismisses Barnett v. Obama in its entirety.

Not as wild a ride as Judge Land’s earlier dismissal in Rhodes v. Obama, but Judge Carter schools Orly in his own calm, measured way—even suggesting that he found Gary Kreep to be the more competent counsel for the Plaintiffs. Zing! 

UPDATE: I hope Orly is wearing her flame-retardant lashes when she reads Carter’s closing rebuke:

Plaintiffs have encouraged the Court to ignore these mandates of the Constitution; to disregard the limits on its power put in place by the Constitution; and to effectively overthrow a sitting president who was popularly elected by “We the People”–over sixty-nine million of the people. Plaintiffs have attacked the judiciary, including every prior court that has dismissed their claim, as unpatriotic and even treasonous for refusing to grant their requests and for adhering to the terms of the Constitution which set forth its jurisdiction. Respecting the constitutional role and jurisdiction of this Court is not unpatriotic. Quite the contrary, this Court considers commitment to that constitutional role to be the ultimate reflection of patriotism. Therefore, for the reasons stated above, Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED.

UPDATE 2: The backlash begins in the Texas Broadcasting readers’ forum, erstwhile domain of rival birther Ed Hale:

JUDGE DAVID CARTER, YOU HAVE JUST GIVEN YOUR LIFE TRAITOR!

Posted by StrangeAppar8us on 10/29/09 at 01:16 PM • Permalink

Categories: PoliticsBarack ObamaBedwettersElection '08Nutters

Share this post:  Share via Twitter   Share via BlinkList   Share via del.icio.us   Share via Digg   Share via Email   Share via Facebook   Share via Fark   Share via NewsVine   Share via Propeller   Share via Reddit   Share via StumbleUpon   Share via Technorati  

At one point Carter stops short of calling one of the plaintiffs a traitor.  I also love the footnote where he says the inclusion of Michelle Obama who holds no office baffles him.  And finally, he says it appears Taitz may have attempted to get her witnesses to commit perjury.

Disbarment next?

Hopefully the CA bar will step in now.

While Carter hasn’t been pushed - yet - to emulate Land, he does manage to deliver this wonderfully deft shiv.

In discussing the standing of the unsuccessful candidates who were party to the suit because they claim Obama was not qualified to run, Land explores the question as to whether there’s a threshold of electoral success that a lesser candidate like Keyes must cross before the ineligibility of another candidate damages him, and summarizes thusly:

If there should in fact be a dividing line for that is dependent on the likelihood of success in the election, then this is not a case which would hover on that line as Plaintiffs received only four-hundredth of one percent of the vote.  The Court may have already met this entire group of voters at the hearings on this matter.

strange, wouldn’t “you have just given your life traitor” be considered a threat against a federal judge?

Rather more serious than “fist-a-cuffs.”

Polly, indeed. A forward to the FBI and the Secret Service is definitely in order.

And yet these people who make threats against sitting presidents and judges are the ones Correntewhiner and Chicbob weep big sloppy tears over when they are mocked by Rachel Maddow and others as “teabaggers.”

Oh for the love of, I don’t know, Texas tea.

Threatens a federal judge and posts the Doobie Brothers.

Armed insurrection just ain’t what it used to be.

It’s getting even hotter in Texas:

CARTER IS A TRAITOR TO THE OFFICE, TO HIS COUNTRY AND TO THE OATH HE TOOK AS A MARINE…. It is time for a full out revolution and we have to get rid of all of them, not just Obama, but EVERY ONE OF THOSE THAT ARE RUINING OUR COUNTRY. OH,... AND I FORGOT TO SAY THAT CARTER IS A TRAITOR TO THE CONSTITUTION and our (very sane) hope that this could all be solved in a decent manner as the Constitution has willed us to do, he simply threw out all of our protections that are built into said Constitution for protection from exactly this type of thing happening, out the window with the baby and the bathwater. I hope that he sleeps well at night when he sees what will start happening soon. And that the price he was paid for this abomination ws really high, for he will never be that rich that he can shut his eyes ever again with comfort, because someone will get him!!!!

Expect a lot more of this. Carter was the “patriotic Marine who will do the right thing” they had all their chips on. The Birthers are going to view this as an unspeakable betrayal.

Well, I just emailed the link to the FBI. Time to give Orly’s paranoiacs something to be genuinely paranoid about.

These passages in the ruling ought to concern them more:

Taitz encouraged her supporters to contact this Court, both via letters and phone calls. It was improper and unethical for her as an attorney to encourage her supporters to attempt to influence this Court’s decision. Despite these attempts to manipulate this court, the Court has not considered any outside pleas to influence the Court’s decision.

Additionally, the court has received several sworn affidavits that Taitz asked potential witnesses that she planned to call before this Court to perjure themselves. This Court is deeply concerned that Taitz may have suborned perjury through witnesses she intended to bring before this Court.

Emphasis mine.

Also, it would seem that Carter definitely, positively, absolutely read the famous pOrlynographical affadavit by Lucas.

Poor Judge Carter. He should get hazard pay, and there should be an eyewashing station in his robing room.

Judge Joan Lefkow of Chicago came home a few years ago to find that someone had slaughtered her husband and her mother. She had been the judge in a case involving a white supremacist, so naturally suspicions went there first*, but it turned out the perp was another deranged plaintiff acting alone. So yeah, I think death threats on sitting judges should be taken very seriously indeed.

*The most amusing/disturbing/disgusting thing about this horrible incident was the way the white supremacists demanded “apologies” for having been associated with these murders.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joan_Lefkow

Comment by Oblomova on 10/29/09 at 02:46 PM

...but there is no joy in Mudville - crazy Orly has struck out!

Fantastic news!

But grrrrrr. I was on web conferences all day and couldn’t read email, twitter, here, Politijab and I missed all the fun!

I’m going to pray that these judges have extra security and the the CA bar finally pays attention.

There’s no anything in Orlyville just yet. Her site merely shows rumblings and dark prognostications of unrest, civil discontent, armed insurrection—-the usual.

Often there will be no mention of something unpleasant like the case to which a million hopes and dreams of an Obama-free future being shot not only out of court but practically into space. Then, without comment, the appeal is posted, along with some pleas to research the tenth cousins of long-dead furriners and whatever junk mail Orly has gotten in the past week.

If Ed McMahon were still alive, she’d have posted his Publisher’s Clearinghouse letter as proof that not all of the entertainment industry is subservient to the Indokenyan usurper.

She had been the judge in a case involving a white supremacist, so naturally suspicions went there first*,

backstory trivia:

On January 8, 2003, Hale was arrested, charged with soliciting an undercover FBI informant to kill Judge Joan Lefkow, the United States district court judge presiding over his trademark case.[9]

Glenn Greenwald was the attorney representing Hale (in the trademark violation case) at the time.

*

Man, threatening a judge is some excellent statergerizing. If these bozos ever find themselves in court and their little online rants come up the judge is going to give them the stiffest sentence he can.

The Court may have already met this entire group of voters at the hearings on this matter.

Ka-BOOM!

Mrs. Polly - Yeah, but Zampolit Charlton (who may or maynot be Orly’s boytoy Charles E. Lincoln III) at The Pest and eFail is screaming about Judge Carter’s ruling already.

I bet you that Dr. Orly’s appeal is going to make her appeal to Judge Land look calm and rational in comparison.

Patrick, what is the possibility of any of CL3’s appeals succeeding when the Land appeal failed, despite the fact that it was filed on the Equinox???

And poor Carter is already suffering from TMI-related Stress Disorder anyway.

Who of us can look at Orly and CL3 together again without.. without….

oh, no, horrible! horrible!

Though to be sure, it is very helpful to the Court to be able to place when a filing was made by more than just the date.  April 22 is just April 22, but when the Court reads,

Filed April 22nd, 2009
Executive Assistant’s Day.

it just takes the Court right there.

OK, Orly’s posted a reaction by one of her adherants, smartly titled, “BRING IT ON”

If it takes riots in the streets to stand for the Constitution and kick an illegitimate President out of office, then bring it on.  The civil war took close to 600,000 largely white men to bring freedom for all.  Freedom from Tyranny costs a great price as always.  The usurper could have avoided it all if he was an honest man. That makes two reasons to legally kick him out.

Who wants to call the FBI this time? No, I went last time. Somebody else take a turn!

If it takes riots in the streets to stand for the Constitution and kick an illegitimate President out of office, then bring it on.

Notice that Dentist the Menace isn’t outside throwing rocks. Nope, got an early hairdresser’s appointment.

The civil war took close to 600,000 largely white men to bring freedom for all.

This woman really does not know when to shut up.

The usurper could have avoided it all if he was an honest man.

If that nasty neegro would just stay in his place…

Epic.

Just as in the O.J. Simpson case, our legal system has been used to avoid a ‘perceived’ violent and damaging reaction by the general population to justice being served - and so, one more cowardly judge resorts to tortured logic and avoids doing the right thing.

This lawsuit was never about military personnel avoiding deployment to a war zone!  It has always been about Obama’s ineligibility to serve as President of the United States and to issue orders as Commander-in-Chief, potentially placing hundreds and thousands of lives in harms way.

In dragging his feet about additional troops to Afghanistan, as requested by the very same General he put in charge, Obama has proven that he is more interested in giving the Muslim world a hand than winning a war for the very American citizens that elected him.

Judge David O. Carter has just missed his place in history as a patriot, and instead joined the ranks of cowardly and immoral traitors to the United States Constitution.

Judge Carter’s lack of knowledge beyond his military and legal experience has proven to be his Achilles’ heel.  He most obviously does not understand what the real dangers to our nation are.  Namely, that Obama and his handlers are only interested in dismantling the Constitution and destroying the Dollar, in order to surrender American sovereignty and make way for the North American Union and a New World Order.

Obama and his ilk probably believe that in this New World Order, with the backing of International Law and hate crime legislation, supported by multiple nuclear-armed Islamic groups and countries; that somehow, we are all going to reach ‘détente’ and live happily ever after.

Maybe Judge Carter does not understand that Islam will not stop until it conquers the entire world and converts it to follow its ways, or die trying.

Judge Carter definitely does not understand that there is enough evidence this very day that Obama is not only a fraud, but that all of his actions thus far betray a childish ideology and a most distinct loyalty to the Muslim world.  To say that this is evidence of a ‘divided loyalty’ would be to give him too much credit for attempting to achieve a balance.  This just simply is not the case.

The truth will eventually come out.  However, it may be too late to save our Republic.

God help the next Judge Carter that is tested during this critical time in American history.  All we need is one righteous man to stand up for the truth.  God save America.

Ooooooh look everyone, a drive-by Orlybot!

He’s already spammed the same scrawl at Scribd, the poor, permanently disappointed wingnut.

He’s a bit like tedbot with a functioning spellcheck and capslock key but an overweening predilection for ‘scare quotes.’

Oh, and now also American Grand Jury and the Post & Email.

This lawsuit was never about military personnel avoiding deployment to a war zone!  It has always been about Obama’s ineligibility to serve as President of the United States and to issue orders as Commander-in-Chief, potentially placing hundreds and thousands of lives in harms way.

[snip]

Judge Carter’s lack of knowledge beyond his military and legal experience has proven to be his Achilles’ heel.

Hee-larious.

If all we need is one honest man to stand up for the truth, why the fuck are you asking a non-existent God to save America you thimbledick?

What’s it going to be, is your Super-duper God coming or not, because if he isn’t, please sit down and have a coke and a smile and shut the fuck up.

We’ve heard all about your God, his son, his son’s dirty fucking hippie friends and the sketchy skater grrrrlzz they hang out with, so please, have that omnipotent, omniscient motherfucker either show up or shut up about it already.

I don’t think he can hear you, HB. He’s wandered into the hilarious Wingnut of Wingnuttia AXJ forums, a convolved labyrinth from which few if any commenters ever return.

In fact, one of them has been driven to such a pitch of dementia that he’s struggling (so far unsuccessfully) to master the haiku form:

The document, itself, was
difficult to comprehend,
but this makes it clear
for us lay people.
...
Marching by the millions
will make a statement that
can’t be ignored. Calling
for Impeachment is necessary
and soon.

Wow.  North American Union and New World Order. 

Here’s the deal, you need to take your meds every single day for them to be effective.  They sell these cool little containers with a compartment for each day.  Buy one.  It’ll help.

I must say it’s Carter’s fault for taking these jokers seriously and devoting countless hours and a great deal of effort to their frivolous garbage. Had he dismissed it summarily he wouldn’t be facing the birther invective deluge he’s facing now.

I think future judges have learned to not give these clowns the time of day or any daylight at all.

Page 1 of 1 pages

Sorry, commenting is closed for this post.

<< Back to main