oh dear god, I’m so going to hell. -bites lip-
HT, on December 14th, 2008 at 6:21 pm Said:
delurking…Johninca, what can I write that hasn’t already been posted. Awesome talent. You too Swan!
It’s so nice to lurk at a place that is hone to so many brilliant and talented people. For awhile, before this blog started, almost a year ago, I thought that intelligent discourse was dead. I’ve been here daily ever since…
Nell, on December 14th, 2008 at 6:50 pm Said:
While your meter and rhyme may not be perfect, Swannie, I find the message of your poem far more nuanced and subtle than the sophomoric sledge hammer of other poets I’ve read elsewhere.
I nominate you for Confluence Poet Laureate.
swanspirit, on December 14th, 2008 at 9:58 pm Said:
NELL you are so sweet to nominate me hugs to you !!! And i am so flattered you like my writing !!
( do we have a POET LAUREATE ?? ) but if anyone deserves it it is
Johninca. He is SO much more talented and prolific than i coud ever hope to be ,and my efforst are sporadic and unstructured .
Thanks everyone for all the nice things you have said you all are too kind !!
Love and hUGS
Swannie
Nell, on December 14th, 2008 at 10:13 pm Said:
Swannie–quantity does not trump quality. My vote for Confluence Poet Laureate still goes to you. That one (male) amateur poet thinks it is his prerogative to critique the work another (female) amateur poet is the height of hubris (IMHO). I look forward to reading more of your poetry.
johninca, on December 14th, 2008 at 10:27 pm Said:
Nell, I am presently the poet laureate here, but I do not hold that position jealously; it were Riverdaughter’s alone to bestow or take away.
I wish to let your criticism of me stand, while clarifying one thing.
It is not my prerogative to critique Swanspirit. I love Swanspirit.
She asked my opinion and I gave it; that is all.
You look forward to reading her poetry. So do I. You read it because I asked her to post it here, on my thread.
You will have your wish, which is also my wish, to see more of her work– if she allows me to post it.
You will never find me upset at any fair critique of my work, or at your opinion of the superiority of Swan’s work. For me, the only devastating critique is the reader’s silence. –john
Nell, on December 14th, 2008 at 11:56 pm Said:
I do not see where Swanspirit asked for anyone’s critique of her
poetry, only permission to post it.
John, I find your constant need for approval of your poetic efforts rather sad, but if Riverdaughter has designated you Poet Laureate, so be it. That’s her prerogative. Frankly, if I were RD, I’d find your worshipful adulation downright creepy.